Cookie Love is a custom cookie bakery located in Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

We create fun and delicious cookies for your special occasions.

Choose from our gallery or request a design of your own!

  • thanksgiving-smallassorted

    Seasonal: Fall!

    Celebrate Thanksgiving with sweet treats from Cookie Love!

    Assorted Fall Themed Cookies: $38 per dozen

    Order Thanksgiving Cookies by November 14th!


  • thanksgiving-mrandmrsturkey

    Seasonal: Thanksgiving!

    Celebrate quality family time with sweet treats from Cookie Love!

    Mr. & Mrs. Turkey: $60 per dozen
    Add names to create custom Thanksgiving table place cards that are good enough to eat!

    Order Thanksgiving Cookies by November 14th!


  • PYO-Turkeys

    Featured: Paint Your Own!

    Design the perfect party favor or kid's activity...

    Wet the colored food-safe ink or icing dots with the included brush and paint your own masterpiece.

    Paint Your Own Cookie: $6 each (minimum order of 6)

Our Cookies

Custom Decorated Cookies

Our cookies are always freshly made to order, so they taste as good as they look!

Whether elegantly laid on a place setting or playfully arranged on a dessert table, your guests will be delighted to find a unique and edible treat awaiting them!

Choose a design from our gallery or request something unique to your occasion.

handpaintedpinkbarn

Vanilla Sugar Cookies

Flour

Sugar

Butter

Eggs

Salt

Baking powder

Pure vanilla bean paste

Almond emulsion (contains no nut allergens)

Lemon Sugar Cookies

+ Pure lemon extract

Dark Chocolate Sugar Cookies

+ Unsweetened cocoa powder

Royal Icing

Pasteurized egg whites

Confectioner's sugar

Lemon juice

Salt

Pure vanilla extract

Corn syrup

Food grade glycerin


Cookie Cakes

Celebrate the holidays, a birthday, or a special event with a moist and chewy, super sized, chocolate chip cookie cake!

Decorated with familiar American buttercream in your choice of greeting.

9" (feeds 6-8 people): $25.00

12" (feeds 8-10 people): $35.00

14" (feeds 12-15 people): $45.00

Cookie Cake


Homestyle Cookies

Baked fresh the morning of your delivery, our homestyle cookies are classic favorites everyone loves! Made with whole ingredients and no preservatives or artificial flavors (with the exception of optional colored sprinkles). Cookies are approximately 2”-3” in size.

Per dozen: $15
Minimum order is 2 dozen.

Flavors (you may choose different flavors per dozen):

  • Chocolate Chip
  • Cape Cod Oatmeal Cranberry
  • S'Mores
  • M&M
  • Cinnamon Sugar Snickerdoodle
  • Lemon Glazed Shortbread
  • Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Cookies

Cookie Cake

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What cookie flavors are available?

  • We offer vanilla, lemon, chocolate, and "Funfetti" sugar cookies.

    The cookies are decorated with vanilla or lemon royal icing, which is a tasty, sweet glaze that dries firm, but is not rock hard like many royal icings.

  • What are the sizes of your cookie favors?

  • Cookie favors are approximately 4", with some shapes available in a smaller or larger size. Just ask!

  • How are cookies packaged?

  • Decorated cookies are individually packaged in clear cello bags and heat sealed for freshness. Optional satin ribbon tied at the tops of the bags is available for an additional $4.00 per dozen. Homestyle Cookies and Cookie Cakes come in a clear window bakery box. Other packaging/boxing options available upon request.

  • What is the shelf life of your cookies?

  • Because Cookie Love cookies contain no preservatives, they taste best when eaten within 1-4 days of receiving. Cookies can also be frozen in an airtight container for up to 1 month. If freezing decorated cookies, please ask for more detailed instructions.

  • Do your cookies contain nuts?

  • No, they do not; however, the cookies are made in a facility that is not nut free.

    Email us if you have other questions.

  • How far in advance should I order my cookies?

  • In general, 2 weeks notice before your event is appreciated; however, we will try our best to accommodate orders with shorter notice whenever possible. Even if you don’t know your exact design or quantity, we can still hold a spot on the cookie schedule.

  • Do you ship?

  • Unfortunately we do not ship, due to the fact that we cannot guarantee orders once a carrier takes possession of it.

  • How much do your cookies cost?

  • Cookies are priced according to the amount of details (see below), colors, size, and complexity. Things like airbrushing, metallic colors, and hand painting will increase the price. There is a minimum order of 1 dozen cookies of the same design and colors. Please email or call for a price quote.

    BASIC
    basic

    Starts at $36 per dozen

    DETAILED
    detailed

    Starts at $48 per dozen

    ELABORATE
    elaborate

    Starts at $60 per dozen

About Cookie Love and Pastry Chef Kristen Chang

Hi, I'm Kristen Chang. Welcome to Cookie Love! What can I tell you about myself? Well, I found my love for baking at an early age "experimenting" with my mom's Betty Crocker Cookbook. Fast forwarding to college, I received a degree in textile design from the Rhode Island School of Design before returning to my first love by enrolling at the Johnson and Wales University and earning a degree in Baking and Pastry Arts. I've since had the privilege to bake at several fine bakeries including Nashoba Brook Bakery in West Concord, Massachusetts, and the Black Forest Bakery and Cafe in Amherst, New Hampshire.

Cookie Love represents my dream to marry my passions in design and baking to create cookies that look beautiful and taste delicious as well. I'm always working on new designs, so please stop by often and follow Cookie Love on Facebook.

Order Now!

By Email
By Phone

Pricing & Minimum Order

In general, cookies range in price between $3.50-$5.00 each but can vary depending on the amount of detail involved. There is a minimum order of 1 dozen cookies of the same design and colors. Please email or call for a price quote on custom cookie designs.


Payment

We accept Venmo, cash, and checks. Payment is due in full upon placing your order. Until then, your order is not guaranteed.


Deliveries

We cater to within a 60 mile radius of Yarmouthport, Massachusetts. Delivery is free within 15 minutes of Yarmouthport. Outside of that, a fee applies depending upon location. You may also pick up your order in Yarmouthport.


Cancellations

In the event you need to cancel an order, please let us know at least 1 week prior to your order delivery date for a refund. Any cancellations within 1 week of your order delivery date will forfeit any refund. We appreciate your understanding.